Parsha Q&A - Parshas Lech Lecha

Parshas Lech Lecha

For the week ending 11 Cheshvan 5759 / 30 & 31 October 1998

Contents:

Parsha Questions

Sherlox Holmes

I Did Not Know That!

Parsha Questions

Answers | Contents

What benefits did Hashem promise Avraham if he would leave his home?
"And all the families of the earth will be blessed through you." What does this mean?
Who were the souls that Avraham and Sarah "made?"
What were the Canaanites doing in the Land of Canaan when Avraham arrived?
Why did Avraham build an altar at Ai?
What two results did Avraham hope to achieve by saying that Sarah was his sister?
Why did Avraham's shepherds rebuke Lot's shepherds?
Who was Amrafel and why was he called that?
Verse 14:7 states that the four kings "smote all the country of the Amalekites." How is this possible since Amalek had not yet been born?
Why did the "palit" tell Avraham that Lot had been captured?
Who accompanied Avraham into battle against the four kings?
Why was Avraham unable to pursue the four kings past Dan?
Why did Avraham give "ma'aser" to Malki-Tzedek specifically?
Why didn't Avraham accept any money from the king of Sodom?
When did the decree of four hundred years of exile begin?
What did Hashem indicate with His promise to Avraham that he would "come to his ancestors in peace?"
How did Hashem fulfill His promise to Avraham that he would be buried in "a good old age?"
Why did the Jewish People need to wait until the fourth generation until they returned to Eretz Canaan?
Who was Hagar's father?
Why did Avraham fall on his face when Hashem appeared to him?

Solution Contents	Sherlox Holmes And The Precision Mystery Two figures sat in a coach on the rumbling train. "Good thing you and I arrived early at the train station," said world famous detextive Sherlox Holmes. "This train was scheduled to leave at 3:18, but in fact it left at 3:17. Had we been precisely on time, we would have missed it. It's not always good to be too precise." "Speaking of the number 318, I'm puzzled by the following verse: Avraham armed his disciples - three hundred and eighteen.... (Bereshis 14:14)." "What's puzzling?" asked Sherlox. "It's Rashi's comment that confuses me. Rashi says that the plural word 'disciples' (chanichav) is written as though it were singular (chanicho), indicating that there was in fact only one disciple, Eliezer. To complicate matters, the verse states explicitly that there were 318 people. Rashi explains this by saying that the numerical value of Eliezer is exactly equal to 318." "Brilliant observation!" said Sherlox. "Perhaps, but why must Rashi depart from the straightforward explanation? Why must he resort to numerical values to explain a simple verse?" "You answered that yourself, Dr. Watstein: The word disciples is written as though it were singular, indicating that it was indeed only one person." "As you well know, Mr. Holmes, the Torah often writes plural words as though they were singular (for example, Shmos 27: 11 and Devarim 33:9) and Rashi makes no comment. So why here does Rashi comment?" "It's not always good to be too precise, Dr. Watstein."

Solution
Contents

Sherlox Holmes And The Precision Mystery

Two figures sat in a coach on the rumbling train. "Good thing you and I arrived early at the train station," said world famous detextive Sherlox Holmes. "This train was scheduled to leave at 3:18, but in fact it left at 3:17. Had we been precisely on time, we would have missed it. It's not always good to be too precise."

"Speaking of the number 318, I'm puzzled by the following verse: Avraham armed his disciples - three hundred and eighteen.... (Bereshis 14:14)."

"What's puzzling?" asked Sherlox.

"It's Rashi's comment that confuses me. Rashi says that the plural word 'disciples' (chanichav) is written as though it were singular (chanicho), indicating that there was in fact only one disciple, Eliezer. To complicate matters, the verse states explicitly that there were 318 people. Rashi explains this by saying that the numerical value of Eliezer is exactly equal to 318."

"Brilliant observation!" said Sherlox.

"Perhaps, but why must Rashi depart from the straightforward explanation? Why must he resort to numerical values to explain a simple verse?"

"You answered that yourself, Dr. Watstein: The word disciples is written as though it were singular, indicating that it was indeed only one person."

"As you well know, Mr. Holmes, the Torah often writes plural words as though they were singular (for example, Shmos 27: 11 and Devarim 33:9) and Rashi makes no comment. So why here does Rashi comment?"

"It's not always good to be too precise, Dr. Watstein."

I Did Not Know That!

"And you will call his name Yitzchak…(17:19)"

Why was Avraham's name changed (from Avram - Bereishis 17:5) and Yaakov's name changed (to Yisrael - Bereishis 32:29), whereas Yitzchak's name remained unchanged?

Avraham and Yaakov received their names from their parents, while Yitzchak received his name from Hashem.

(Jerusalem Talmud - Berachos 1:6)

Answers to this Week's Questions

Questions | Contents

All references are to the verses and Rashi's commentary, unless otherwise stated

What benefits did Hashem promise Avraham if he would leave his home?
12:1 - He would become a great nation, and his excellence would become known to the world, and he would be blessed with wealth.
"And all the families of the earth will be blessed through you." What does this mean?
12:3 - A person will say to his child, "You should be like Avraham."
Who were the souls that Avraham and Sarah "made?"
12:5 - People they converted to the worship of Hashem.
What were the Canaanites doing in the Land of Canaan when Avraham arrived?
12:6 - They were in the process of conquering the land from the descendants of Shem.
Why did Avraham build an altar at Ai?
12:8 - He foresaw the Jewish People's defeat there in the days of Yehoshua due to the sin of Achan. He built an altar there to pray for them.
What two results did Avraham hope to achieve by saying that Sarah was his sister?
12:13 - That the Egyptians would let him live and give him presents.
Why did Avraham's shepherds rebuke Lot's shepherds?
13:7 - Lot's shepherds grazed their flocks in privately owned fields.
Who was Amrafel and why was he called that?
14:1 - Amrafel was Nimrod. He said (amar) to Avraham to fall (fel) into the fiery furnace.
Verse 14:7 states that the four kings "smote all the country of the Amalekites." How is this possible since Amalek had not yet been born?
14:7 - The Torah is using the name that the place would bear in the future.
Why did the "palit" tell Avraham that Lot had been captured?
14:13- He hoped Avraham would die trying to save Lot, so that he himself might be able to marry Sarah.
Who accompanied Avraham into battle against the four kings?
14:14 - His servant, Eliezer.
Why was Avraham unable to pursue the four kings past Dan?
14:14 - He saw prophetically that his descendants would erect a golden calf there. As a result his strength failed.
Why did Avraham give "ma'aser" to Malki-Tzedek specifically?
14:20 - Because Malki-Tzedek was a kohen.
Why didn't Avraham accept any money from the king of Sodom?
14:23 - Hashem had promised Avraham wealth, and Avraham didn't want the King of Sodom to be the one to take credit for it.
When did the decree of four hundred years of exile begin?
15:13 - With the birth of Yitzchak.
What did Hashem indicate with His promise to Avraham that he would "come to his ancestors in peace?"
15:15 - That his father, Terach, repented and became righteous.
How did Hashem fulfill His promise to Avraham that he would be buried in "a good old age?"
15:15 - Avraham lived to see his son, Yishmael, repent and become righteous, and he died before his grandson, Esav, became wicked.
Why did the Jewish People need to wait until the fourth generation until they returned to Eretz Canaan?
15:16 - They needed to wait until the Amorites had sinned sufficiently to deserve expulsion.
Who was Hagar's father?
16:1 - Pharaoh.
Why did Avraham fall on his face when Hashem appeared to him?
17:3 - Because he was as yet uncircumcised.

Mystery Contents	Solution to Sherlox Holmes "My intuition," said Sherlox, "tells me that the answer is as follows: Whenever the Torah counts soldiers, the Torah speaks in terms of round numbers. For example: In Bamidbar 1:20-43, each number is a multiple of fifty." "Go on," said Watstein. "It is quite out of character for the Torah to say that Avraham had precisely 318 men. The normal way would be to give a round number, such as 300." "Come to think of it," said Watstein, "the same is true elsewhere in Tanach; for example: Gidon, and the three hundred men who were with him (Shoftim 8:4)." "Yes, Tanach is replete with such examples. So, to say that Avraham took precisely 318 men is jarring to the ear sensitive to the Torah's subtle nuance." "I see!" said Watstein. "If 318 refers to the actual number of people, it is too precise! Therefore, Rashi offers the midrashic explanation, one which seeks precision by being less precise!" "Precisely, dear Watstein." (Sherlox" is by Reuven Subar, inspired by Dr. Avigdor Bonchek's "What's Bothering Rashi")

Mystery
Contents

Solution to Sherlox Holmes

"My intuition," said Sherlox, "tells me that the answer is as follows: Whenever the Torah counts soldiers, the Torah speaks in terms of round numbers. For example: In Bamidbar 1:20-43, each number is a multiple of fifty."

"Go on," said Watstein.

"It is quite out of character for the Torah to say that Avraham had precisely 318 men. The normal way would be to give a round number, such as 300."

"Come to think of it," said Watstein, "the same is true elsewhere in Tanach; for example: Gidon, and the three hundred men who were with him (Shoftim 8:4)."

"Yes, Tanach is replete with such examples. So, to say that Avraham took precisely 318 men is jarring to the ear sensitive to the Torah's subtle nuance."

"I see!" said Watstein. "If 318 refers to the actual number of people, it is too precise! Therefore, Rashi offers the midrashic explanation, one which seeks precision by being less precise!"

"Precisely, dear Watstein."

(Sherlox" is by Reuven Subar, inspired by Dr. Avigdor Bonchek's "What's Bothering Rashi")

Written and Compiled by Rabbi Eliyahu Kane & Rabbi Reuven Subar
General Editor: Rabbi Moshe Newman
Production Design: Eli Ballon
© 1998 Ohr Somayach International - All rights reserved. This publication may be distributed to another person intact without prior permission. We also encourage you to include this material in other publications, such as synagogue newsletters. However, we ask that you contact us beforehand for permission, and then send us a sample issue.

This publication is available via E-Mail

Ohr Somayach Institutions is an international network of Yeshivot and outreach centers, with branches in North America, Europe, South Africa and South America. The Central Campus in Jerusalem provides a full range of educational services for over 685 full-time students.

The Jewish Learning Exchange (JLE) of Ohr Somayach offers summer and winter programs in Israel that attract hundreds of university students from around the world for 3 to 8 weeks of study and touring.

The Ohr Somayach Home Page is hosted by TeamGenesis

Ohr Somayach	Sections	Follow
About Ohr Somayach International Branches Contact Us Donate	Home Explore Judaism Study In Israel Audio

Ohr Somayach

https://ohr.edu

Parsha Q&A - Parshas Lech Lecha

Parshas Lech Lecha

Parsha Questions

Sherlox Holmes And The Precision Mystery

I Did Not Know That!

Recommended Reading List

Answers to this Week's Questions

Solution to Sherlox Holmes